top of page

Reasons why Major League players are forced into retirement

5 minutes ago
5 min read

Even the most talented Major League players begin to show signs of decline once they pass the age of 35. There is a passage that captures this reality quite succinctly. This passage comes from the remarkably brilliant and entertaining book "Big Data Baseball: Math, Miracles, and the End of a 20-Year Losing Streak", by Travis Sawchik in 2015:

"DiamondView revealed Barry Bonds was the only hitter in the prior twenty-two seasons who produced at an elite level after the age of thirty-five."


A truly remarkable and entertainment book "Big Data Baseball: Math, Miracles, and the End of a 20-Year Losing Streak" by Travis Sawchik (Paperback edition, Flatiron Books, 2016)
A truly remarkable and entertainment book "Big Data Baseball: Math, Miracles, and the End of a 20-Year Losing Streak" by Travis Sawchik (Paperback edition, Flatiron Books, 2016)
The Japanese translation of the above book (translated by Takeshi Kuwata, Kadokawa Shoten Publishing Co., Ltd., 2016)
The Japanese translation of the above book (translated by Takeshi Kuwata, Kadokawa Shoten Publishing Co., Ltd., 2016)

DiamondView, mentioned here, is a database developed in-house by the Cleveland organization; its first version was completed in 2000.

When I read this, my initial reaction was, "Fair point—that makes sense." However, I found two specific details I'd like to challenge:

① During the 22-year period covered by DiamondView, Tony Gwynn led the National League in batting average for four consecutive years, from age 34 (1994) to age 37 (1997). Does this mean Tony Gwynn wasn't performing at an "elite level"? Is it because his OPS figures were too low? At age 34 (1994), Gwynn posted an incredible .394 batting average and an OPS of 1.022; however, in the years that followed, his OPS fell below 1.0. At age 37 (1997), his batting average remained quite high at .372, but his OPS was .957. Even so, I find it difficult to definitively claim that a player—who leads the league with such an outstanding batting average—isn't performing at an "elite level." What do you think? Does an OPS of 1.0 or higher really serve as the absolute threshold for being considered "elite"?

② It is true that Barry Bonds maintained an OPS of over 1.0 even after the age of 35, and one could certainly say he produced elite-level results. However, wasn't this achieved under the controversial circumstance of steroid use? Given that, I must admit I am reluctant to regard him as the only hitter to have performed at an elite level past the age of 35.

While there are certain finer points I find difficult to fully accept, it remains true that even the most gifted hitters tend to decline—and see their performance drop—once they pass the age of 35, even if there are a very small number of exceptions.

So, why does this happen after the age of 35? Even this excellent book does not address why players—with the exception of Barry Bonds—are unable to perform at an elite level once they pass 35. Perhaps it is considered so self-evident that there is no need to even mention it? In other words, is it simply that human power and speed naturally decline with age, and therefore, baseball players over 35 inevitably show signs of decline, leading to a drop in their performance?

What must be kept in mind here is that the data from DiamondView presented in this excellent book concerns only hitters; it says nothing about pitchers. In other words, there may well be differences in how age-related decline manifests in fielders (position players) versus pitchers.

Before exploring this further, let me take a brief digression.


Observations regarding the decline of aging Major League players frequently appear in literature, columns, and other writings. I will share two examples here—from authors I deeply admire and frequently read: Stephen King and Kurt Vonnegut.

First, a passage from Stephen King's novel "The Colorado Kid":

"Even Willie Mays dropped a pop-up from time to time, I guess, especially toward the end of his career."


"The Colorado Kid" by Stephen King (Paperback edition, Hard Case Crime, 2019)
"The Colorado Kid" by Stephen King (Paperback edition, Hard Case Crime, 2019)
The Japanese translation of the above book (translated by Roh Shiraishi and Mayumi Takayama, Bungeishunju Ltd., 2024)
The Japanese translation of the above book (translated by Roh Shiraishi and Mayumi Takayama, Bungeishunju Ltd., 2024)

Next, a remark by Kurt Vonnegut himself, taken from a "Playboy" interview included in his collection "Wampeters, Foma & Granfalloons":

"But I'm sort of like Ted Williams now—I shuffle up to the plate."

5) "WAMPETERS, FOMA & GRANFALLOONS" by Kurt Vonnegut (Paperback edition, The Dial Press, A Division of Random House Inc., 2006)
5) "WAMPETERS, FOMA & GRANFALLOONS" by Kurt Vonnegut (Paperback edition, The Dial Press, A Division of Random House Inc., 2006)
The Japanese translation of the above book (translated by Shigeo Tobita, Hayakawa Publishing Corporation, 1988)
The Japanese translation of the above book (translated by Shigeo Tobita, Hayakawa Publishing Corporation, 1988)

Both examples cited here refer to fielders (position players), though I did not choose them with that specific intent. It seems to me that when literature and other writings touch upon the decline of baseball players, they almost invariably focus on fielders. I cannot recall a single instance where the decline of a pitcher is mentioned. Even if such examples do exist—and I simply happen to be unaware of them—I suspect they are far fewer in number than those concerning fielders.


As baseball players pass the age of 35, they often begin to show signs of decline, and their performance starts to suffer. While it is true—as mentioned earlier—that power and speed diminish with age, I believe there is another significant factor at play: the deterioration of dynamic visual acuity. One individual has pinpointed the connection between this and the decline of baseball players: Sadaharu Oh, a superstar who hit a record 868 career home runs in Japanese professional baseball and twice won the Triple Crown.

In a book (1) authored by Yutaka Enatsu—a renowned pitcher who served as a fierce rival to Sadaharu Oh during his playing days and once set an astounding record of 401 strikeouts in a single season—Sadaharu Oh contributed a piece. In it, he writes the following:

"Once you pass the age of 35, your dynamic visual acuity gradually begins to decline.... While many pitchers continue to play well into their forties, hitters—as their vision fades—start to perceive fastballs as moving even faster, and breaking pitches as having more pronounced movement. Around the age of 36 or 37, I began to sense that something was off.

Even though my physical power hadn't significantly declined, I found myself getting jammed more often. Since the game is decided in fractions of a second, a slight deterioration in my eyesight meant I was getting tied up on inside pitches or losing out in head-to-head physical duels. Consequently, my home run total dropped, and my batting average fell as well. I retired in 1980—the same year I hit 30 home runs—and some people expressed regret, saying, "But you're still capable of hitting 30 home runs!" However, I didn't believe I could perform at a level that would allow me to aim for 40 home runs the following season, so I decided to retire—and I did so without any lingering hesitation."

Sadaharu Oh Memorial DVD: "The World's Big 1" (VAP, INC., 2008)
Sadaharu Oh Memorial DVD: "The World's Big 1" (VAP, INC., 2008)

In this passage, Sadaharu Oh clearly states that the decline in performance associated with aging differs between fielders (position players) and pitchers, explaining that this is because a decline in dynamic visual acuity has a greater impact on the play of fielders. I agree with this assessment. While it is true that a loss of power and speed also contributes to age-related decline, one must not overlook the deterioration of dynamic visual acuity as a significant factor.


It is well known—and frequently pointed out—that a baseball player's performance tends to decline as their dynamic visual acuity wanes with age; yet, it seems to be something that many people often overlook.


While scientific advancements now make it possible to slow the rate at which dynamic visual acuity declines, the speed and "sharpness" (movement/break) of pitchers' deliveries are evolving even faster. Ultimately, the decline in dynamic visual acuity that comes with aging likely remains a major factor that forces hitters into retirement.


<Reference>

1) Enatsu's Final Message by Yutaka Enatsu with Takarin Matsunaga (in Japanese, SHOGAKUKAN Inc., May 2026)



(If I've made a mistake or left out something important, please let me know. I'll try to make corrections or additions.)

bottom of page